Blog

Hit and Run lawyer in Toronto

Failure to Remain at the Scene: When an Accident is No Accident

Failure to remain at the scene of an accident can be charged as a crime under the Criminal Code or as a provincial offence under the Highway Traffic Act. 

The charges a person might face depend on which statute the police decide to proceed under.

Criminal Code Charges

The Criminal Code provides for three different types of failure to stop crimes with different legal penalties:

  • Failure to stop at an accident. This general charge can result in a fine of up to $5,000 and up to ten years of imprisonment.
  • Failure to stop at an accident involving bodily harm. The severity of physical injury leads to the possibility of increased punishment. A conviction can result in a fine of up to $5,000 and up to 14 years of imprisonment.
  • Failure to stop at an accident involving death. This severe category can result in a sentence of life imprisonment and different minimum punishments.

Ontario Highway Traffic Act

Ontario traffic law requires every driver involved in a traffic accident to stop and provide the police or the other driver with their name, address, driver’s licence number, and insurance information. 

Failure to follow this law can result in:

  • A fine of up to $2,000
  • A jail sentence of up to six months
  • A two-year suspension of driving privileges
  • Seven demerit points added to the offender’s driving record 

When an Accident Is No Accident

The Criminal Code states that it is a crime for a person in control of a vehicle involved in an accident to fail to stop and provide information. The Ontario Highway Traffic Act addresses failure to remain at the scene of an accident. 

In the 2021 case of R. v. Reid, the Court of Appeal of Newfoundland and Labrador directly addressed how “accident” should be defined under the law regarding fleeing the scene. The court found that “accident” includes any incident involving a motor vehicle that causes physical injury to persons or vehicles, regardless of the driver’s intent. 

That broad interpretation is critically important for defence lawyers when considering how to defend these types of criminal charges.

Rights and Responsibilities After an Accident

Leaving the scene of an accident can have immediate and long-term consequences. Even if an incident seems minor, you should always stop and exchange the required information to avoid the risk of criminal prosecution. 

Of course, everyone should remain on scene and call for emergency services if necessary. You should never leave a scene involving physical injury until authorities have arrived and cleared you to depart.

Call Graham Zoppi for Experienced Criminal Defence Representation

Failure to remain at the scene after an accident could lead to criminal charges. Have you been charged with this crime? It’s time to seek legal representation. 

Graham Zoppi has been defending Ontario residents in criminal cases for more than 20 years, and he is prepared to assist you. Call (416) 873-6970 today to schedule a professional and confidential consultation with a criminal defence lawyer in Toronto.

© 2026 Graham Zoppi Criminal Lawyer | All Rights Reserved | Sitemap | Legal SEO by Logik Digital